# Competency questions for ontology v1 (docs/ontology-v1-plan.md, step 1; 2026-10-19). # Each question states what the graph must return (expect), what it must never return (forbid) and where the right # answer is "not known" (unknown). Pilot papers: [20] [26] [37] [43] [58] [65] [71] [73]. # Sources: the paper text (data/text/.txt: author-contribution statement, methods, acknowledgements) and the # byline as printed (sources/site/people.json). astra checks every expected answer against the text # (scripts/cq_check.py) before these become SPARQL tests (step 9). - id: CQ1 ask: Who performed the DFT calculations in [26], and at which institution printed on [26]? ask_ko: '[26]에서 DFT 계산은 누가, [26]에 적힌 어느 기관 소속으로 했는가?' expect: - person: Kwangsoo Kim role: computation institution: Korea Institute of Energy Research evidence: 'Kwangsoo Kim: DFT calculation' - person: Byung-Hyun Kim role: computation institution: Korea Institute of Energy Research evidence: 'Byung-Hyun Kim: computer simulation & writing' forbid: - person: Ji Chan Park role: computation - person: Kyung Hee Oh role: computation - id: CQ2 ask: Who performed the calculations in [20]? ask_ko: '[20]의 계산은 누가 했는가?' unknown: '[20] has no author-contribution statement; the activity''s performer is unknown. The lab''s authorship (Byung-Hyun Kim, KIER) is co-authorship, not attribution.' forbid: - any_person_as: computation_performer - id: CQ3 ask: In [71], what did each author contribute, and who made the samples? ask_ko: '[71]에서 저자별 기여는 무엇이고, 시료는 누가 만들었는가?' expect: - person: Se-Eun Shin role: supervision evidence: S.E.S. directed the research project - person: Seon-min Kim role: synthesis institution: Sunchon National University evidence: S.M.K. and S.Y.G. designed and produced the samples also: sample design ("designed and produced the samples") - person: Seoyoon Gong role: synthesis institution: Sunchon National University - person: JaeBeom Hwang role: formal_analysis evidence: J.B.H., B.H.K. and D.H.B. analyzed the data - person: Byung-Hyun Kim role: formal_analysis - person: Donghyun Bae role: formal_analysis - all_authors: true role: discussion evidence: All authors discussed and commented on the results note: not writing / editing unknown: who ran the DFT simulations of [71] is not stated (activity performer unknown) forbid: - person: Se-Eun Shin role: computation - id: CQ4 ask: In the pilot papers, which partner institutions made or tested the samples in papers whose calculations the lab took part in, and for which reactions? ask_ko: 파일럿 논문 중 연구실이 계산에 참여한 논문에서, 시료를 만들거나 시험한 공동연구 기관과 그 반응은? expect: - paper: 26 institution: Korea Institute of Energy Research reaction: dry_reforming evidence: 'Kyung Hee Oh: experiment' - paper: 71 institution: Sunchon National University reaction: corrosion role: synthesis lab_role: formal_analysis note: the lab took part in the analysis; no person is named for the DFT, but per group the lab did it (inferred; CQ13) - paper: 26 institution: Korea University via: Kyung Hee Oh, dual affiliation (Korea University, KIER) role: experiment note: affiliation-level link; the paper does not say where the experiment was done forbid: - paper: 65 any_partner_as: experiment - paper: 37 institution: Hyundai Motor Company role: synthesis - paper: 37 any_partner_as: synthesis_or_testing note: computation-only; experimental values are cited from the literature - paper: 71 person: - Seon-min Kim - Seoyoon Gong role: testing note: they made the samples; the tests are not attributed - id: CQ5 ask: Does [65] report any measured performance (e.g. in seawater), or only computed and ML-predicted values? ask_ko: '[65]에 측정된 성능(예: 해수 전해)이 있는가, 아니면 계산·ML 예측값만 있는가?' expect: - paper: 65 value_origins: - computation - ml_prediction forbid: - paper: 65 value_origin: measurement - id: CQ6 ask: In [65], are the on-top and FCC-hollow Ni-substituted Pt(111) zone models (M9, M10) one material? ask_ko: '[65]의 on-top 영역 모델(M9)과 FCC-hollow 영역 모델(M10)은 같은 물질인가?' expect: - paper: 65 distinct: - M9 - M10 - paper: 65 ensemble: M23 - paper: 65 design_space: M25 forbid: - paper: 65 same_referent: - M9 - M10 note: M9 and M10 differ as adsorption-site zone models, not as bulk materials; the 60-configuration ensemble (M23) is not the union of M9 and M10. - id: CQ7 ask: Which pilot papers acknowledge NRF grant RS-2024-00453815, and what do they study? ask_ko: 파일럿 논문 중 NRF 과제 RS-2024-00453815를 사사한 논문과 그 연구 대상은? expect: - paper: 65 grant: RS-2024-00453815 funder: National Research Foundation of Korea - paper: 71 grant: RS-2024-00453815 funder: National Research Foundation of Korea - paper: 73 grant: RS-2024-00453815 funder: National Research Foundation of Korea note: '[71] names the grant under ''the Korean Government (MSIT)''; the NRF link is from the site''s project record (projects.project_no) and [65]/[73].' expect_topics: 65: Ni–Cu–Pd–Ag–Pt HEA catalysts for seawater electrolysis (OER, CER selectivity, HER) by active learning + DFT 71: Al–O/CNT composites, corrosion inhibition by Al–O–C anchoring (salt spray, DFT) 73: Re-doped SrZrxIr1-xO3 perovskite for acidic OER / PEM electrolysis - id: CQ8 ask: In [37], what did the Hyundai Motor Company authors contribute? ask_ko: '[37]에서 현대자동차 소속 저자들의 기여는?' expect: - person: Byeongsun Jun roles: - methodology - software - writing_review_editing - person: Yong Jun Jang roles: - investigation - resources - writing_review_editing - person: Sun Ho Choi roles: - investigation - resources - writing_review_editing - person: Seong Hyeon Choi roles: - resources - writing_review_editing - person: Sung Man Cho roles: - resources - writing_review_editing - person: Young-Gu Kim roles: - resources - writing_review_editing note: the paper prints 'Yong-Gu Kim' (byline and statement); the site's DB has 'Young-Gu Kim' — check the DB name - id: CQ9 ask: Where did Kwangsoo Kim work on [26] and on [65]? ask_ko: '[26]과 [65]에서 김광수의 소속은?' expect: - paper: 26 person: Kwangsoo Kim institution: Korea Institute of Energy Research - paper: 65 person: Kwangsoo Kim institution: Korea University forbid: - paper: 65 person: Kwangsoo Kim institution: Korea Institute of Energy Research - id: CQ10 ask: Did the lab compute anything in [43], and what was the PI's contribution? ask_ko: '[43]에서 연구실은 계산을 했는가, 교수의 기여는?' expect: - person: Byung-Hyun Kim roles: - investigation evidence: 'B.-H. K.: Investigation' check: 'Reported calculations: thermodynamic-equilibrium modelling (Gibbs free-energy minimisation, HSC Chemistry 9, SI Figs. S3–S5) and Debye–Scherrer crystallite sizes; no DFT reported; performer not stated. "B.-H. K.: Investigation" does not attribute a calculation.' unknown: whether the lab performed any calculation of [43] - id: CQ11 ask: For a value the site shows, which model extracted it, on which page is the evidence, and was it corrected or reviewed? ask_ko: 사이트에 보이는 값 하나에 대해, 어느 모델이 뽑았고 근거는 몇 쪽이며 수정·검토되었는가? expect: - assertion: any value of the pilot papers has: - generated_by_model - extraction_date - evidence_page - review_status - paper: 48 value: V48 corrected: true source: the pipeline (extractions/, vocab/corrections.yaml, the student review sheet), not the paper; astra cannot check it from the text - id: CQ12 ask: Which papers study oxygen evolution, found through Wikidata's item for it (Q4147614), not our own term? ask_ko: 우리 용어가 아니라 Wikidata의 산소 발생 항목(Q4147614)으로 찾을 때, 산소 발생을 다룬 논문은? expect: - {all_papers_with_reaction: OER, via: 'ReactionType#OER skos:broadMatch wd:Q4147614'} note: >- the graph's own term stays the IRI; the Wikidata link is a SKOS mapping (broadMatch - our OER is the electrochemical reaction, Q4147614 the process of oxygen evolution in general), never owl:sameAs. - id: CQ13 ask: In which papers did the lab do the calculations (its PI or members performed, supervised or directed them), and on what basis? ask_ko: 연구실이 계산을 한(교수나 연구실 구성원이 수행·지도한) 논문은 어느 것이고, 근거는 무엇인가? expect: - {paper: 57, basis: stated, note: 'Maheepal Yadav (Hanyang, another group) ran the DFT; the PI supervised it (PI, 2026-10-20)'} - {paper: 26, basis: stated, note: 'Kwangsoo Kim and Byung-Hyun Kim: DFT calculation'} - {paper: 71, note: 'the paper names nobody for the DFT; the lab is the computational group'} - {paper: 65} forbid: - {paper: 70, note: no calculations} - {paper: 55, note: 'no simulation setup (DRT fitting of measured impedance)'} note: per group, not per person (PI, 2026-10-20 — matching each author to an activity is close to impossible from the papers); alchem:PartOfWork prov:wasAssociatedWith alchem:lab, with alchem:basis stated or inferred.